Dhanvantree

Dhanvantree

Dhanvantree

Commodity Funds: Gold ETFs, Silver ETFs, FoFs, and SEBI Rules

Table of Contents

Unlike equity or debt mutual funds that hold corporate shares or interest-bearing bonds, commodity funds in India center primarily on gold and silver bullion held inside Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) while Fund of Funds (FoFs) hold units of those underlying ETFs. Regulated under SEBI’s 2026 mutual fund framework, these schemes follow dedicated bullion purity, domestic spot valuation, and exchange-trading rules.

Dhanvantri Capital Services Private Limited, known as Dhanvantree, is an AMFI-registered mutual fund distributor, ARN-194216. Our role is limited to distributing mutual fund products. We do not manage the schemes or portfolios. We name no scheme on this page. The choice is yours.

What Indian commodity funds can hold—and what SEBI prohibits

Investors accustomed to international financial media sometimes assume a commodity mutual fund buys baskets of crude oil, copper, wheat, and natural gas futures. In India, Gold and Silver ETFs and their FoFs are the principal retail mutual-fund structures for precious-metal exposure, while other permitted schemes may participate in exchange-traded commodity derivatives under specific category rules.

Under the SEBI (Mutual Funds) Regulations, 2026 and the consolidated SEBI Master Circular for Mutual Funds dated 20 March 2026, mutual fund commodity exposure operates across defined instruments and limits:

  1. Physical Gold Bullion (Inside Gold ETFs): Gold ETFs invest primarily in physical gold and permitted gold-related instruments, and may hold up to 5 percent in debt and money-market instruments. Under the SEBI Master Circular, held bullion must consist of standard gold bars with a fineness of 995 parts per thousand (99.5 percent purity) conforming to London Bullion Market Association (LBMA) Good Delivery standards (noting that LBMA London Good Delivery bars carry 350–430 fine troy ounces rather than a universal 1-kilogram bar weight).

  2. Physical Silver Bullion (Inside Silver ETFs): Silver ETFs invest primarily in physical silver and permitted silver-related instruments, and may hold up to 5 percent in debt and money-market instruments. Held bullion must consist of standard silver bars with a fineness of 999 parts per thousand (99.9 percent purity) conforming to LBMA Good Delivery standards.

  3. Units of Gold and Silver ETFs (Inside Precious-Metal FoFs): Gold FoFs, Silver FoFs, and blended Gold-Silver FoFs do not hold bullion bars directly; instead, they invest in units of underlying domestic Gold ETFs and/or Silver ETFs, allowing transactions through standard mutual fund channels.

  4. Exchange-Traded Commodity Derivatives (ETCDs) and Physical Settlement: Mutual funds may participate in ETCDs in India, except in derivatives on Sensitive Commodities. Gold and Silver ETFs and other permitted scheme categories may participate subject to scheme-specific limits, approved policies, and applicable position limits:

    • Category Caps: Multi-Asset Allocation schemes may invest up to 30 percent of NAV in ETCDs, while other Hybrid schemes (excluding Multi-Asset Allocation schemes) are subject to a 10 percent of NAV limit. These scheme-category limits are not extra allowances that can simply be added to other exposure limits. How three-asset portfolios combine commodities with equities and fixed income is detailed under multi asset allocation funds.

    • Single-Commodity and ETF Rules: Under paragraph 13.16.9 of the Master Circular, ETCD exposure to a single commodity is generally capped at 10 percent of scheme NAV, except for Gold and Silver ETFs investing in derivatives with gold or silver as the underlying. Under paragraph 4.2.13, Gold ETFs have a separate 50 percent NAV ceiling for cumulative exposure to gold-related instruments (including Gold Deposit Scheme, Gold Monetisation Scheme, and gold-backed ETCDs combined), with Gold Deposit Scheme and Gold Monetisation Scheme exposure together capped at 20 percent of NAV within that 50 percent limit, and any unused portion of that 20 percent allowance usable for gold-backed ETCDs. Silver ETFs have a 10 percent NAV limit for silver-backed ETCDs (except where the scheme intends to take physical delivery rather than roll over the contract), and their cumulative gross exposure cannot exceed 100 percent of net assets.

    • Policy Approval and Review: General ETCD participation requires written investment and valuation policies approved by the AMC Board and Board of Trustees, while the specific Gold ETF and Silver ETF provisions require annual policy review. Mutual funds must also avoid net short positions in any commodity after accounting for physical holdings and ETCD positions.

    • Physical Settlement Disposal: Under paragraph 13.16.2, if a scheme receives physical goods through ETCD settlement, it must dispose of them as early as possible within prescribed maximum periods: 180 calendar days from the date of holding for gold or silver; by the immediate next expiry day of the same contract series for other commodities; or within 30 calendar days from the date of holding where final expiry occurs before the next expiry day.

Independent statutory auditors conduct physical verification of gold and silver held in custody every half-year.

How SEBI's April 2026 valuation shift changed gold and silver NAVs

Historically, Indian Gold and Silver ETFs valued bullion using international benchmark fixings converted into rupees with customs duties, taxes, and notional premiums or discounts. Through Circular No. HO/(68)2026-IMD-POD-2/I/5780/2026 (Valuation of physical Gold and Silver held by mutual fund schemes, dated 26 February 2026), SEBI aligned physical gold and silver valuation with domestic exchange spot prices:

  • Polled Domestic Spot Prices: Physical gold and silver held by mutual fund schemes are valued using polled spot prices published by recognised stock exchanges in India used for settling physically delivered gold and silver derivatives contracts.

  • Uniform AMFI Policy: AMFI, in consultation with SEBI, has prescribed a uniform valuation policy across asset management companies.

  • Practical Effect: This framework is intended to improve uniformity and reduce differences in valuation inputs across schemes.

Daily unit pricing mechanics across mutual fund categories are explained under net asset value.

Gold ETFs: structure, purity rules, and exchange execution

A Gold ETF is an exchange-traded scheme tracking the domestic price of physical gold of 995 fineness (LBMA Good Delivery standards), with unit-level gold exposure varying by scheme and its NAV rather than a universal fixed gram figure per unit.

Creation Units, ₹25 Crore Rule, and Liquidity Window Conditions

Retail investors buy and sell Gold ETF units on recognised stock exchanges through a demat and trading account. Authorised participants and large investors can transact directly with the AMC in Creation Unit Size (disclosed by the AMC in the scheme’s Scheme Information Document).

Direct AMC transactions by investors other than market makers are generally available only for transactions exceeding ₹25 crore. However, investors can approach the AMC for redemption without exit load even for smaller amounts if any of these three conditions occurs (with applications received by 3 PM in these circumstances processed at that day’s closing NAV):

  1. The ETF’s closing traded price is at a discount of more than 1 percent to its day-end NAV for seven continuous trading days.

  2. No quotes are available on the stock exchange for three consecutive trading days.

  3. The total exchange bid size is less than half the creation-unit size, averaged daily over seven consecutive trading days.

Under Regulation 66(7) of the SEBI (Mutual Funds) Regulations, 2026, Gold ETFs carry a Base Expense Ratio (BER) ceiling of up to 0.90 percent, with applicable brokerage, transaction costs, and statutory levies reflected separately in the Total Expense Ratio (TER). Detailed expense rules are covered under expense ratio.

Silver ETFs: industrial demand drivers, storage bulk, and volatility profile

A Silver ETF tracks the domestic price of physical silver of 999 fineness (LBMA Good Delivery standards). Because silver serves both industrial applications (such as solar panels and electronics—approximately 58 percent of global demand in 2025 per World Silver Survey 2026 data) and precious-metal demand, and trades in a smaller market than gold, silver prices can exhibit wider swings and higher physical vaulting bulk per rupee of value than gold. Like Gold ETFs, Silver ETFs carry a BER ceiling of up to 0.90 percent (with separate brokerage, transaction costs, and statutory levies in TER).

Gold and Silver Fund of Funds (FoFs): access without a demat account

A Gold Fund of Funds, Silver Fund of Funds, or Gold-Silver Fund of Funds invests in units of underlying Gold and/or Silver ETFs rather than holding physical bullion directly. Investors can transact in Statement of Account (SOA) or demat mode without placing direct exchange order-book trades.

For mutual fund purchase orders, applicable NAV depends on funds being available for utilisation by the scheme by 3:00 PM; for redemption applications, requests received by 3:00 PM generally receive that day’s closing NAV. Under SEBI’s Master Circular, Fund of Funds schemes publish their NAV by 10:00 AM on T+1 because underlying ETF units are valued using exchange closing prices. Under Regulation 66(7) and Regulation 66(8), the 0.90 percent overall BER ceiling for relevant FoFs includes the weighted-average BER of underlying ETFs, and the FoF’s own BER layer is subject to the twice-weighted-average restriction within that overall ceiling. Full two-layer FoF rules are detailed under invest in fund of funds.

Side-by-side comparison: Gold ETF vs. Gold Fund (FoF) vs. Sovereign Gold Bond

The table below compares Gold ETFs, Gold Fund of Funds, and Sovereign Gold Bonds (SGBs) across structure, costs, and holding rules:

Comparison Parameter Gold ETF Gold Fund of Funds (FoF) Sovereign Gold Bond (SGB)
Structure & Custody Exchange-traded MF holding 995 fineness physical gold in vault custody Open-ended MF investing in Gold ETF units (SOA or demat mode) Government security issued by RBI on behalf of the Government of India
Expenses & Investor Charges BER up to 0.90%; brokerage, transaction costs, and statutory levies in TER; exchange/broker charges on trades (DP charges typically apply on demat debits such as sales; account maintenance fees are separate) 0.90% overall BER ceiling includes weighted-average underlying ETF BER; FoF BER layer subject to 2x weighted-average cap under Reg. 66(8) No recurring MF TER; secondary exchange trades involve broker and exchange charges
Acquisition & Liquidity Continuous exchange trading; direct AMC creation/redemption above ₹25 crore (or under specific liquidity-window conditions) Daily MF transactions (3:00 PM fund-utilisation cut-off for purchases; T+1 10:00 AM NAV) No new tranche announced since 2023-24 Series IV (issued February 2024); secondary exchange trades and permitted off-market transfers/gifts to eligible holders

Broader sovereign debt rules appear under government securities, and capital gains tax rules across ETFs and FoFs are detailed under long term capital gains tax on mutual funds.

Why ETF market prices drift from physical gold and silver prices

An ETF’s exchange market price can trade at a premium or discount to underlying value due to fund expenses, cash holdings, intraday order imbalances, and exchange trading mechanics. The exchange-published indicative NAV (iNAV) is based on the latest available gold or silver data and may be static or dynamic depending on the availability of the underlying price.

Gold and Silver ETFs are subject to a 2 percent annualised tracking-error limit, calculated using rolling one-year data; in unavoidable force-majeure circumstances beyond an AMC’s control, the limit may be exceeded, subject to reporting to the trustees and corrective action.

Under SEBI’s ETF trading framework effective 7 September 2026, Gold and Silver ETFs participate in the pre-open call auction with an initial price band of ±6 percent (expandable by 3 percentage points at a time after the cooling-off period) and an initial base price set by the previous trading day’s last-30-minute volume-weighted average price (with fallback to last traded price or prior closing NAV, transitioning from 1 April 2027 to the previous day’s closing NAV as the reference base price).

Full ETF mechanics are covered under exchange traded funds and category context under types of mutual funds.

Key risks and practical checks before choosing a precious-metal fund

Precious-metal prices fluctuate with global macro factors, real interest rates, and currency movements, and carry no guaranteed return or fixed income. Before investing, review the scheme’s SID, KIM, latest TER/BER disclosures, tracking error, and liquidity metrics.

Questions investors ask about commodity funds

What do commodity funds in India invest in?

Gold and Silver ETFs hold physical gold (995 fineness) or silver (999 fineness) and may hold up to 5 percent in debt and money-market instruments, while precious-metal FoFs invest in units of those ETFs and permitted hybrid schemes may use ETCDs within prescribed caps.

What is the difference between a Gold ETF and a Gold Fund (FoF)?

A Gold ETF holds physical gold and trades on stock exchanges (requiring a demat and trading account), whereas a Gold FoF invests in Gold ETF units and can be transacted as an open-ended mutual fund without a demat account

Why can an ETF's market price differ from its underlying value?

Market prices can trade at a premium or discount due to expenses, cash holdings, order imbalances, and exchange price-band mechanics, while iNAV reflects the latest available gold or silver data (static or dynamic depending on underlying price availability).

Are new Sovereign Gold Bond (SGB) tranches available?

No new tranche has been announced since 2023-24 Series IV, issued in February 2024; existing tranches trade on exchanges or can be transferred off-market/gifted to eligible holders per applicable rules.

Disclaimer: The views expressed here are of the author and do not reflect those of Dhanvantree. Mutual funds are subject to market risks, please read the scheme documents carefully before investing.

Ready to level up your Investment? Reach out.